Larger Font   Reset Font Size   Smaller Font  

This Road We Traveled

Jane Kirkpatrick

  © 2016 by Jane Kirkpatrick

  Published by Revell

  a division of Baker Publishing Group

  P.O. Box 6287, Grand Rapids, MI 49516-6287

  Ebook edition created 2016

  All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means—for example, electronic, photocopy, recording—without the prior written permission of the publisher. The only exception is brief quotations in printed reviews.

  ISBN 978-1-4934-0513-8

  Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is on file at the Library of Congress, Washington, DC.

  Scripture used in this book, whether quoted or paraphrased by the characters, is taken from the King James Version of the Bible.

  This book is a work of historical fiction based closely on real people and events. Details that cannot be historically verified are purely products of the author’s imagination.

  “Dramatic and suspenseful, This Road We Traveled is an unforgettable story of hardship, survival, and the bonds of family, based on true events. Tabby’s indomitable spirit proves that women, as well as men, helped to tame the West.”

  —Suzanne Woods Fisher, bestselling author of Anna’s Crossing

  Praise for The Memory Weaver

  “Storyteller Jane Kirkpatrick puts flesh and blood on the bones of history. In The Memory Weaver, she breathes life into the little-known tale of Eliza Spalding, daughter of the famed missionaries, who survives unspeakable horrors to become a woman of love and faith and strength. Set against an authentic nineteenth-century background, this is a superb story of a woman’s struggle to triumph over time and place. The Memory Weaver is a memorable book.”

  —Sandra Dallas, New York Times bestselling author

  Praise for A Light in the Wilderness

  “Kirkpatrick gives marvelous insight into the struggle of the freed slave, the adventurous lure of the Oregon Trail with the numerous potentials it promised, and the tremendous amount of faith it took to endure.”

  —CBA Retailers + Resources

  “Kirkpatrick exercises her considerable gift for making history come alive.”

  —Publishers Weekly

  “This heart-stirring new historical novel has romance, mystery, and adventure. Characters are sweet, charming, strong, witty, and looking for their places in the world. One character is loosely based on the true story of the first African American woman to cross the Oregon Trail to live in freedom. Kirkpatrick has done her research and gives detailed descriptions without overwhelming the reader and the story.”

  —RT Book Reviews

  Dedicated to Jerry,

  who walks many roads with me

  No one knows and we would have to figure everything out ourselves.

  Rinker Buck in The Oregon Trail: A New American Journey

  Cast of Characters

  Tabitha (Tabby) Moffat Brown matriarch of Brown family

  Clark Brown (deceased) Tabby’s husband

  John Brown Tabby’s brother-in-law and former sailor

  Orus Brown & Lavina oldest Brown son and his second wife; 13 children

  Manthano Brown & Catherine Tabby’s youngest son and second wife; Young Pherne and other children

  Pherne & Virgil Pringle Tabby’s only daughter and her husband

  Virgilia oldest Pringle daughter

  Clark oldest Pringle son

  Octavius, Albro, Oliver (deceased) Pringle sons

  Sarelia Lucia, Emma Pherne, Mary Ella youngest Pringle daughters

  *Judson Morrow ox driver

  Jesse Applegate originator of Southern cutoff trail

  Captain Levi Scott pilot, guide for Applegate cutoff trail

  **Nellie Louise Blodgett traveler on the Oregon Trail

  Fabritus Smith Oregon farmer and legislator

  Harvey & Emeline Clark independent missionaries in Forest Grove

  * imagined character representative of people of the time

  ** based on a real person from another century



  Title Page

  Copyright Page

  Endorsement Page


  Cast of Characters


  Part One

  1. Tabby’s Plan

  2. Pherne’s Watch

  3. Virgilia’s Hope

  4. Orus’s Report

  5. What He Didn’t Say

  6. Considerations

  7. The Reality of Things

  8. Choices

  9. Sorting

  10. Divers Seasons, Divers Climes

  11. Last Arguments

  12. We Are Call’d

  Part Two

  13. To Choose

  14. What Friends We Make

  15. To Keep from Falling

  16. Waiting on Guidance

  17. A Fork in the Road

  18. Moon in Morning Milk

  19. The Form of Things Unknown

  20. It Comes to This

  21. Great Acts of Loving

  22. Doing Good

  23. Grief and Guilt

  24. The Wisdom of Bones

  Part Three

  25. Orus Says

  26. Tired of Choosing

  27. Resting Place

  28. The Hearth of Her Heart

  29. Six and One-Quarter Cents

  30. New Trails

  31. Reconciled

  32. The Varieties of Manna

  33. Frontiers

  34. As Vast as the Pacific

  35. Feet or Wings

  Author’s Notes and Acknowledgments


  Author Interview

  Reader Group

  About the Author

  Also by Jane Kirkpatrick

  Back Ads

  Back Cover




  It was a land of timber, challenge, and trepidation, forcing struggles beyond any she had known, and she’d known many in her sixty-six years. But Tabitha Moffat Brown decided at that moment with wind and snow as companions in this dread that she would not let the last entry in her memoir read “Cold. Starving. Separated.” Instead she inhaled, patted her horse’s neck. The snow was as cold as a Vermont lake and threatening to cover them nearly as deep while she decided. She’d come this far, lived this long, surely this wasn’t the end God intended.

  Get John back up on his horse. If she couldn’t, they’d both perish.


  The elderly man in his threadbare coat and faded vest sank to his knees. At least he hadn’t wandered off when he’d slid from his horse. His white hair lay wet and coiled at his neck beneath a rain-drenched hat. His shoulder bones stuck out like a scarecrow’s, sticks from lack of food and lost hope.

  “You can’t stop, John. Not now. Not yet.” Wind whistled through the pines and her teeth chattered. “Captain!” She needed to sound harsh, but she nearly cried, his name stuck in the back of her throat. This good man, who these many months on the trail had become more than a brother-in-law, he had to live. He couldn’t die, not here, not now. “Captain! Get up. Save your ship.”

  He looked up at her, eyes filled with recognition and resignation. “Go, Tabby. Save yourself.”

  “Where would I go without you, John Brown? Fiddlesticks. You’re the captain. You can’t go down with your ship. I won’t allow it.”

  “Ship?” His eyes took on a glaze. “But the barn is so warm. Can’t you smell the hay?”

  Barn? Hay? Trees as high as heaven marked her view, shrubs thick and slowing as a nightmare clogged their path, and all
she smelled was wet forest duff, starving horseflesh, and for the first time in her life that she could remember, fear.

  Getting upset with him wouldn’t help. She wished she had her walking stick to poke at him. Her hands ached from cold despite her leather gloves. She could still feel the reins. That was good. What a pair they were: he, old and bent and hallucinating; she, old and lame and bordering on defeat. Her steadfast question, what do I control here, came upon her like an unspoken prayer. Love and do good. She must get him warm or he’d die.

  With her skinny knees, she pushed her horse closer to where John slouched, all hope gone from him. Snow collected on his shoulders like moth-eaten epaulets. “John. Listen to me. Grab your cane. Pull yourself up. We’ll make camp. Over there, by that tree fall.” She pointed. “Come on now. Do it for the children. Do it for me.”

  “Where are the children?” He stared up at her. “They’re here?”

  She would have to slide off her horse and lead him to shelter herself. And if she failed, if her feet gave out, if she couldn’t bring him back from this tragic place with warmth and water and, yes, love, they’d both die and earn their wings in Oregon country. It was not what Tabitha Moffat Brown had in mind. And what she planned for, she could make happen. She always had . . . until now.


  Tabby’s Plan



  Tabitha Moffat Brown read the words aloud to Sarelia Lucia to see if she’d captured the rhythm and flow. “Feet or wings: well, feet, of course. As a practical matter we’re born with limbs, so they have a decided advantage over the wistfulness of wings. Oh, we’ll get our wings one day, but not on this earth, though I’ve met a few people who I often wondered about their spirit’s ability to rise higher than the rest of us in their goodness, your grandfather being one of those, dear Sarelia. Feet hold us up, help us see the world from a vantage point that keeps us from becoming self-centered—one of my many challenges, that self-centered portion. I guess the holding up too. I’ve had to use a cane or walking stick since I was a girl.”

  “How did that happen, Gramo?” The nine-year-old child with the distinctive square jaw put the question to her.

  “I’ll tell you about the occasion that brought that cane into my life and of the biggest challenges of my days . . . but not in this section. I know that walking stick is a part of my feet, it seems, evidence that I was not born with wings.” She winked at her granddaughter.

  “When will you get to the good parts, where you tell of the greatest challenge of your life, Gramo? That’s what I want to hear.”

  “I think this is a good start, don’t you?”

  “Well . . .”

  “Just you wait.”

  Tabitha dipped her goose quill pen into the ink, then pierced the air with her weapon while she considered what to write next.

  “Write the trouble stories down, Gramo. So I have them to read when I’m growed up.”

  “When you’re grown up.”

  “Yes, then. And I’ll write my stories for you.” A smile that lifted to her dark eyes followed. “I want to know when trouble found you and how you got out of it. That’ll help me when I get into trouble.”

  “Will it? You won’t get into scrapes, will you?” Tabby grinned. “We’ll both sit and write for a bit.” The child agreed and followed her grandmother’s directions for paper and quill.

  The writing down of things, the goings-on of affairs in this year of 1845, kept Tabby’s mind occupied while she waited for the second half of her life to begin. Tabby’s boys deplored studious exploits, which had always bothered her, so she wanted to nurture this grandchild—and all children’s interest in writing, reading, and arithmetic. So far, the remembering of days gone by had served another function: a way of organizing what her life was really about. She was of an age for such reflection, or so she’d been told.

  Whenever her son Orus Brown returned from Oregon to their conclave in Missouri, she expected real ruminations about them all going west—or not. Perhaps in her pondering she’d discover whether she should go or stay, and more, why she was here on this earth at all, traveling roads from Connecticut southwest to Missouri and maybe all the way to the Pacific. Wasn’t wondering what purpose one had walking those roads of living a worthy pursuit? And there it was again: walking those roads. For her it always was a question of feet or wings.

  Sarelia had gone home long ago, but Tabby had kept writing. Daylight soon washed out the lamplight in her St. Charles, Missouri, home, and she paused to stare across the landscape of scrub oak and butternut. Once they’d lived in the country, but now the former capital of Missouri spread out along the river, and Tabby’s home edged both city and country. A fox trip-tripped across the yard. Still, Tabby scratched away, stopping only when she needed to add water to the powder to make more ink. She’d have to replace the pen soon, too, but she had a good supply of those. Orus, her firstborn, saw to that, making her several dozen before he left for Oregon almost two years ago now. He was a good son. She prayed for his welfare and wondered anew at Lavina’s stamina managing all their children while they waited. Well, so was Manthano a good son, though he’d let himself be whisked away by that woman he fell in love with and rarely came to visit. Still, he was a week’s ride away. Children. She shook her head in wistfulness. Pherne, on the other hand, lived just down a path. And it was Pherne, her one and only daughter, who also urged her to write her autobiography. “Your personal story, Mama. How you and Papa met, where you lived, even the wisdom you garnered.”

  Wisdom. She relied on memory to tell her story and memory proved a fickle thing. She supposed her daughter wanted her to write so she wouldn’t get into her daughter’s business. That happened with older folks sometimes when they lacked passions of their own. She wanted her daughter to know how much being with her and the children filled her days. Maybe not to let her know that despite her daughter’s stalwart efforts, she was lonely at times, muttering around in her cabin by herself, talking to Beatrice, her pet chicken, who followed her like a shadow. She was committed to not being a burden on her children. Oh, she helped a bit by teaching her grandchildren, but one couldn’t teach children all day long. Of course lessons commenced daily long, but the actual sitting on chairs, pens and ink in hand, minds and books open, that was education at its finest but couldn’t fill the day. The structure, the weaving of teacher and student so both discovered new things, that was the passion of her life, wasn’t it?

  Still, she was intrigued by the idea of recalling and writing down ordinary events that had helped define her. Could memory bring back the scent of Dear Clark’s hair tonic or the feel of the tweed vest he wore, or the sight of his blue eyes that sparkled when he teased and preached? She’d last seen those eyes in life twenty-eight years ago. She had thought she couldn’t go on a day without him, but she’d done it nearly thirty years. What had first attracted her to the man? And how did she end up from a life in Stonington, Connecticut, begun in 1780, to a widow in Maryland, looking after her children and her own mother, and then on to Missouri in 1824 and still there in winter 1845? Was this where she’d die?

  “‘A life that is worth writing at all, is worth writing minutely and truthfully.’ Longfellow.” She penned it in her memoir. This was a truth, but perhaps a little embellishment now and then wouldn’t hurt either. A story should be interesting after all.

  His beard reached lower than his throat. Orus, Tabby’s oldest son, came to her cabin first. At least she assumed he had, as none of his children nor Pherne’s had rushed through the trees to tell her that he’d already been to Lavina’s or Virgil and Pherne’s place. It was midmorning, and her bleeding hearts drooped in the August heat.

  “I’m alive, Mother.” He removed his hat, and for a moment Tabby saw her deceased husband’s face pressed onto this younger version, the same height, nearly six feet tall, and the same dark hair, tender eyes.

  “So you are, praise God.” She searched his brown eyes for the spa
rkle she remembered, reached to touch his cheek, saw above his scruffy beard a red-raised scar. “And the worse for wear, I’d say.”

  “I’ll tell of all that later. I’m glad to see you among the living as well.”

  “Come in. Don’t stand there shy.”

  He laughed and entered, bending through her door. “Shyness is not something usually attached to my name.”

  “And how did you find Oregon? Let me fix you tea. Have you had breakfast?”

  “No time. And remarkable. Lush and verdant. The kind of place to lure a man’s soul and keep him bound forever. No to breakfast. I’ve much to do.”

  “So we’ll be heading west then?”

  For an instant his bright eyes flickered and he looked beyond her before he said, “Yes. I expect so.” He kissed her on her hair doily then, patted her back, and said he’d help her harness the buggy so she could join him at Lavina’s. “I’m anxious to spend time with my wife and children. Gather with us today.”

  “I can do the harnessing myself. No tea?”

  “Had some already. Just wanted the invite to come from me.”

  “An invite?”

  He nodded, put his floppy hat back on. “At our place. I’ve stories to tell.”

  “I imagine you do. Off with you, then. I’ll tend Beatrice and harness my Joey.”

  “That chicken hasn’t found the stew pot yet?”

  “Hush! She’ll hear you.” She pushed at him. “Take Lavina in your arms and thank her for the amazing job she’s done while you gallivanted around new country. I’ll say a prayer of thanksgiving that you’re back safely.”

  “See you in a few hours then.”

  “Oh, I’ll arrive before that. What do you take me for, an old woman?” Beatrice clucked. “Keep your opinions to yourself.”

  Orus laughed, picked his mother up in a bear hug, and set her down. “It’s good to see you, Marm. I thought of you often.” He held her eyes, started to speak. Instead he sped out the door, mounting his horse in one fluid movement, reminding her of his small-boy behavior of rarely sitting still, always in motion. Wonder where his pack string is? She scooped up Beatrice, buried her nose in her neck feathers, inhaling the scent that always brought comfort.