Freedom in the Family

  “A MUST-READ FOR THOSE WHO WANT TO KNOW HOW MOVEMENT IS MADE AND SUSTAINED.”

  —JULIAN BOND

  Chairman of the NAACP

  “An important, affecting joint memoir that examines the struggles of … the civil rights movement.”

  —Seattle Post-Intelligencer

  “Compelling … Testaments to the unsung women of the civil rights movement and the visionary local leaders who often toiled in obscurity while facing savagery they knew would go unavenged.”

  —Newark Star-Ledger

  “A fascinating and important new book … A memoir so absorbing and essential that it takes two people to tell.”

  —Oregonian

  “This book is the celebration of an extraordinary woman’s life; it’s well written, interesting, and certainly not the end of the story.”

  —The Denver Post

  “An ennobling insider’s look at the civil rights movement. Patricia and Tananarive Due are two of my new heroes.”

  —CHARLES JOHNSON

  National Book Award–winning author of Middle Passage

  “Underscores the fact that for blacks in America, the struggles of the past are definitely not past. A must-read tale … that connects the dots between then and now.”

  —NATHAN MCCALL

  Author of Makes Me Wanna Holler: A Young Black Man in America

  “POWERFUL …

  Mother and daughter write with an energy that is cathartic in its recounting of past obstacles, and optimistic in its hopes for the future.”

  —Publishers Weekly

  “A living testament to the enduring personal and family consequences of the struggle for freedom and equality.”

  —GLENDA ALICE RABBY

  Author of The Pain and the Promise:

  The Struggle for Civil Rights in Tallahassee, Florida

  “The Dues make it easy for the reader to transition from past to present, but impossible to overlook the sweet sorrow of a mother and daughter having to walk some of the same testy ground on matters racial.”

  —DEBORAH MATHIS

  Author of Yet a Stranger:

  Why Black Americans Still Don’t Feel at Home

  “This book, an insider’s look at the twentieth-century civil rights movement, is personal history at its best.”

  —Deseret News (Salt Lake City)

  “Freedom in the Family … succeeds at doing exactly what the Dues wanted: to write of ordinary people, black and white, doing extraordinary things.”

  —Book Street USA

  “Rare is the book that can take a reader through two generations of activism—and from two women’s points of view. That makes Freedom in the Family a unique way of exploring history and change.”

  —Cape Cod Times

  “Readers will quite likely be both charmed and educated by these dedicated, candid, brilliant women.”

  —Kirkus Reviews

  A One World Book

  Published by The Random House Publishing Group

  Copyright © 2003 by Tananarive Due and Patricia Stephens Due

  All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. Published in the United States by The Random House Publishing Group, a division of Random House, Inc., New York, and simultaneously in Canada by Random House of Canada Limited, Toronto.

  Grateful acknowledgment is made to the following for permission to reprint previously published material:

  GRM Associates, Inc.: Incident from Color by Countee Cullen. Copyright © 1925 by Harper & Brothers; copyright renewed 1953 by Ida M. Cullen. Reprinted by permission of GRM Associates, Inc., Agents for the Estate of Ida M. Cullen.

  Alfred A. Knopf, a division of Random House, Inc.: excerpt from Merry Go Round from The Collected Poems of Langston Hughes by Langston Hughes, copyright © 1994 by The Estate of Langston Hughes. Used by permission of Alfred A. Knopf, a division of Random House, Inc.

  One World and Ballantine are registered trademarks and the One World colophon is a trademark of Random House, Inc.

  www.ballantinebooks.com/one/

  Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 2003093360

  eISBN: 978-0-307-52534-5

  v3.1

  Contents

  Cover

  Title Page

  Copyright

  One: Patricia Stephens Due

  Two: Tananarive Due

  Three: Patricia Stephens Due

  Four: Tananarive Due

  Five: Patricia Stephens Due

  Six: Tananarive Due

  Seven: Patricia Stephens Due

  Eight: Tananarive Due

  Nine: Patricia Stephens Due

  Ten: Tananarive Due

  Eleven: Patricia Stephens Due

  Twelve: Tananarive Due

  Thirteen: Patricia Stephens Due

  Fourteen: Tananarive Due

  Fifteen: Patricia Stephens Due

  Sixteen: Tananarive Due

  Seventeen: Patricia Stephens Due

  Eighteen: Tananarive Due

  Nineteen: Patricia Stephens Due

  Twenty: Tananarive Due

  Twenty-One: Patricia Stephens Due

  Twenty-Two: Tananarive Due

  Twenty-Three: Patricia Stephens Due

  Twenty-Four: Tananarive Due

  Twenty-Five: Patricia Stephens Due

  Twenty-Six: Tananarive Due

  Twenty-Seven: Patricia Stephens Due

  Twenty-Eight: Tananarive Due

  Twenty-Nine: Patricia Stephens Due

  Thirty: Tananarive Due

  Thirty-One: Patricia Stephens Due

  Thirty-Two: Tananarive Due

  Thirty-Three: Patricia Stephens Due

  Photo Inserts

  Dedication

  Acknowledgments: Patricia Stephens Due

  Acknowledgments: Tananarive Due

  Notes

  About the Author

  One

  PATRICIA STEPHENS DUE

  “The American Negro must remake

  his past in order to make his future.”

  —Arthur A. Schomburg

  There are so many misconceptions today about the civil rights movement. People think blacks were a unified front in the “old days,” with everyone marching and holding hands. Well, that’s not true. If only it had been that easy! Just like today, in cities and towns across the South, there were always a select few who lit the fires and went to the meetings—and, eventually, others followed. Dr. Martin Luther King wasn’t the only one lighting the fires. He had a lot of influence, but he was only one man. It concerns me when I hear people say If only we had Martin Luther King today, as if we are helpless without him.

  I wish we had Dr. King today, too. But Dr. King did not create the Movement. There were hundreds and thousands of ordinary people who did extraordinary things. Daily heroism went unrewarded and unrecorded. Some heroes were children, and some were retired. They were maids, ministers, students, teachers, housewives.

  And they suffered! Their families suffered. Their jobs suffered. I know people who never recovered from the Movement. I know people who today cannot bring themselves to talk about what happened to them during that era. I know people who had to spend time in mental institutions. I knew people who committed suicide. I knew people who died. And they were all ordinary people.

  I remember sitting on a textbook committee for schoolchildren in Miami–Dade County a few years ago, and when I asked why the social studies books under consideration mentioned nothing about Tallahassee’s civil rights struggle, school officials tried to tell me that nothing of note had happened in Florida. “I was there!” I protested, but they looked at me as if I were speaking a foreign language. A living witness didn’t matter to them. Without written docum
entation, I was told, the forty-nine days my sister and I spent in jail, the tear gas that burned my eyes, and the people I knew could not be included. As if we had never existed.

  There’s a saying I believe in: History belongs to those who write it.

  I have to write ours.

  Two

  TANANARIVE DUE

  “I could not be sure whether for the rest of my life I would be able to tell when it was really my mother

  or when it was her shadow

  standing between me and the rest of the world.”

  —Jamaica Kincaid

  By the time I was thirteen or fourteen, I was already taller than my mother, but my height was irrelevant to the way I saw our proportions. She might be short physically, but she seemed like a giant. All children believe their parents are larger than life, but that feeling was much more pronounced for me and my two sisters because of the things our mother and father had done. They were civil rights activists. To us, that meant our lives were filled with opportunities no previous generation of blacks who lived in the South had ever known. Ever.

  In our home—where only my father could claim a reliable singing voice, a silky, soothing baritone—freedom songs were every bit as much of the family sing-along repertoire as nursery songs. In fact, we knew the choruses and refrains of 1960s standards like “This Little Light of Freedom,” “We Shall Overcome,” and “Oh, Freedom” better than we knew most Christmas carols. Freedom songs were always the background music of long car trips and annual family celebrations of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s birthday. I can still hear our voices blending together, with my mother’s deep, rolling timbre underneath: And before I’ll be a slave … I’ll be buried in my grave … and go home to my Lord … and be free.

  And, of course, we knew the stories. Like the children of refugees, the children of immigrants, the children of veterans—the children of any survivors who are willing to speak of what they have seen and experienced—my sisters and I were raised on stories at our parents’ knees. We knew that my mother wore dark glasses even indoors and that her eyes had never been right since she was teargassed during a peaceful march in 1960. We knew that she and her sister were part of the student sit-in movement’s landmark first “jail-in,” where they spent forty-nine days in jail rather than pay their bail for the “crime” of sitting at a Woolworth lunch counter. We knew that my father once worked with Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. as a civil rights attorney in St. Augustine, Florida, where Dr. King and hundreds of protestors were arrested.

  That was how we learned who our parents were and, by extension, who we were. My parents were more than parents to me, they were living monuments. As far as we were concerned, they had helped change the world.

  When my parents were concerned about an issue—and they were always concerned about an issue—their telephone calls were returned by everyone from the mayor to then–Dade State Attorney Janet Reno to the school superintendent to legislators. Once, when my mother was upset after black candidates had been passed over in the search for a replacement for a school board member, she put in a call to the state capital and left a message for the governor’s office. That same afternoon, I answered the telephone to hear a man’s voice: “Hi, is Patricia Due there? This is Governor Bob Graham.”

  He called right away. The governor!

  But the excitement was often offset by the price. Once, soon after a Southern federal judge had been killed with a letter bomb, the FBI called my father. The agent told Dad that because of his activism, and particularly his role representing black parents in a long-lasting federal desegregation suit against Miami–Dade County schools, the FBI feared he might be a target for the bomber, a homegrown terrorist. Please, the agent said, be careful about opening unfamiliar mail—just in case.

  The past was not yet past. Not quite.

  And yet, it seems that so few people remember. So few of the storytellers remain.

  That point became all the more poignant to me when I visited the Holocaust Memorial on Miami Beach one afternoon in the summer of 1996, soon after I had taken a long-awaited leave of absence from my job as a reporter at the Miami Herald to write and research this book.

  The memorial is an arresting bronze monolith fashioned in the shape of one reaching, tattooed hand made up of myriad Holocaust victims struggling to climb up from its base. I walked past groups of schoolchildren gathered there, some with lighted candles, as they learned painful portions of their people’s history the way I was being forced that summer to learn details about the more painful portions of mine. My path led to a group of boys younger than ten squatting to listen to tales from an old woman with a thick accent, a woman I knew right away must be a Holocaust survivor. I immediately recognized the fervor of a survivor’s voice.

  I have heard a similar fervor in my mother’s voice many, many times.

  The old woman was telling her story. She told the restless boys, who wore yarmulkes and baseball caps to cover their heads, about how naive she’d been when she’d first been taken to camp, how she hadn’t been hungry and she’d thrown a piece of bread across a fence to feed another hungry man. “Don’t do that,” she was warned, because the time would come when she would learn that food was precious. She learned that soon enough, she said.

  She spoke of being marched across the frozen ground for two weeks when the Russians got closer to their camp. She spoke of being surrounded by bodies of people who had died of disease. She spoke of how frightened everyone was every time they walked in lines at Auschwitz, because they were being led toward the crematorium, and how, when they passed it, one person and then the next would whisper down the line, “We have passed the place,” so they would no longer have to be afraid—that time.

  She talked on, even when the children, distracted, squirmed and turned away. She talked on, despite the midafternoon Miami heat, a perspiration-making heat in the 90s that made all of us long to go inside somewhere cool. She talked on.

  I watched her show the children the green-colored tattoo on her arm, and for the first time she had the children’s undivided interest as they crowded around her for a closer look. “You see?” said the man leading the boys’ group, hoping to seize their interest, to make a lasting impression. “To the Nazis, you weren’t human. To the Nazis, you were an animal, so they put a tattoo on you to identify you, like an animal.”

  Anything to help the children understand. To help them remember.

  She is such an old woman, I thought. Soon, she will be gone, and all of her stories will go with her. I’d had the same thought many times while my mother and I researched the civil rights movement, going through the names of activists she’d known in the 1960s, noting who had already died, and who was dying, their stories vanishing.

  I was very young when I read The Diary of Anne Frank, and that book helped me understand the importance of simply telling a personal story. Because of her diary, Anne Frank was a real person, not a nameless statistic, and her plight was real. Her simple diary is a reminder of a time in history no one wants to repeat. Her diary—and other remarkable stories from Holocaust literature, written by witnesses and survivors—gives voice to those who suffered.

  I had tears in my eyes as I heard the woman’s stories, fixing my gaze on the hollow-eyed, anguished faces and the gaunt, bony figures in the memorial’s sculpture. But I didn’t see any tears in the children’s eyes that day.

  I wondered: Did those children believe that events from sixty years ago do not touch them? Certainly, black children don’t remember a time when they could be lynched in the American South for learning to read, or for whistling at a white woman. Or how, forty years ago, children their own age and people like my parents were forced to risk their lives so the United States Constitution could live up to its own ideals. How they had to fight for even the simplest dignities. How they lived in times when injustice was not only rampant, but it was proud of itself. It was proclaimed on signs. It was upheld in courts.

  Is it all just too awesome
, too remote, for children to imagine?

  I felt deeply inspired by the Auschwitz survivor at the memorial that day, but as I drove away, a nagging question came to me: Where are our storytellers? How many of us are standing in the hot sun to make sure the children of strangers—and even our own—will never, ever forget?

  Three

  PATRICIA STEPHENS DUE

  “A man’s character always takes its hue, more or less, from the form and color of things around him.”

  —Frederick Douglass

  I’ve been a serious person all my life, always the sensible and responsible one. I can’t explain why I’m that way. It’s just my personality. Biologically, I became a woman when I was only nine, when my menstrual period began early. Maybe that made me feel older than most other children. Sometimes it’s a real burden, having to be the one who’s toeing the line when others around me are carefree. Even when I was a child, the people close to me tended to rely on me, to expect me to be strong and self-sufficient. In the end, maybe I became what I was expected to be.

  I like music so much that I have a CD player in almost every room of my house so I can listen to Roy Hamilton, B. B. King, Tina Turner, James Brown, Harry Belafonte, Al Green, Aretha Franklin, Beethoven, and others. I like to laugh and enjoy myself as much as anyone—but there’s a switch in my head that won’t allow me to ignore injustice when I see it. There are many times I’ve wished I could turn that switch off, but that’s not the way it works. It’s on. It always has been, and it always will be. I’ve learned to accept that.

  I was born in 1939 to Lottie Mae Powell and Horace Walter Stephens, although I have very little memory of my parents being married. My father was a local entrepreneur who, I have been told, was running his own restaurant business even while he was in high school. At one time, Daddy was run out of town because many whites, as well as Negroes, frequented his nightclub, and the local white powers threatened him because they wouldn’t tolerate “mixing.” In addition to being a chef, he was also a talented tap dancer. My mother told me many times he was so accomplished that he no doubt would have been famous if he had been white. It’s true there were famous Negro dancers in the 1920s and 1930s, but skin color was, of course, still an obstacle for most Negroes—as it always has been. Discrimination has cost the dreams of many generations of black people in this country, and I believe it was no different for my father.